← Training curriculum

Module 02 · Foundations · Free preview

Vision

Set a clearer vision for the role, the team, and the work product marketing should own.

Approximately 30 minutes

Watch the lesson, or read the full module below.

So, what’s the vision for Cyber PMMs? Will our profession even exist in a decade? If it does, what should it look like? Here’s how I think we should frame our “moonshot” vision for Cyber PMMs: I structured this training in 4 parts: Part 1: Standardizing Cyber PMM Processes Cyber PMMs need standardized processes, tools, and frameworks to handle the wide array of tasks we face. This is foundational. Anyone familiar with the SOAR market knows the importance of workflow automation—and you can’t automate what you don’t understand. Standardizing PMM processes is the first step toward efficiency and scalability. Where to Start?

  • Define repeatable workflows for tasks like messaging creation, content production, and campaign alignment.

  • Build templates and toolkits to minimize the effort required for recurring activities.

  • Integrate these processes into tools like Asana or Jira for visibility and consistency. Part 2: Building an AI Co-Pilot AI isn’t just hype—it’s a practical tool for improving speed, precision, and scale. Let’s let AI handle what it excels at so we can focus on what makes us uniquely human. Potential Applications:

  • Automating the creation of messaging briefs, white papers, or demo scripts.

  • Using AI for content ideation, refinement, and summarization.

  • Enhancing customer research by analyzing large datasets or surveys. AI is already making waves in content generation, task automation, and data analysis. PMMs who master these tools will have a competitive edge. Part 3: Amplifying the Audience PMMs are the voice of the customer. Yet in Cyber, we’re often isolated from customers, which undermines our ability to create value. This has to change. Steps to Reconnect:

  • Advocate for direct access to customer feedback through interviews, surveys, and forums.

  • Work with Sales to secure post-call summaries and CRM insights.

  • Collaborate with Customer Success to understand product adoption challenges. Without direct insight into customer needs and challenges, everything else we do is a shot in the dark. Part 4: Metrics Respect and validation hinge on demonstrating clear, measurable value. Today, most PMMs lack a defined “scoreboard.” This has to change. What Should We Measure?

  • Content Performance: Narrative resonance, lead generation, and influence on pipeline.

  • Buyer Journey Completion: Percentage of content mapped to key personas and stages.

  • Customer Outcomes: Metrics tied to feature adoption, churn reduction, and satisfaction. Metrics bring accountability, and accountability builds credibility. Building a Cyber PMM Roadmap If Cyber PMMs had a roadmap similar to what we request from Product Managers, we’d have clarity about our destination and how to get there. Just like you wouldn’t jump in your car without knowing where you’re headed, PMMs need a vision to guide daily decisions. Let’s aim for a future where Cyber PMMs:

  • Operate within standardized frameworks.

  • Leverage AI as a co-pilot for efficiency.

  • Reclaim our role as the voice of the customer.

  • Define success with measurable, transparent metrics. This is our moonshot. Let’s make it happen. Part 1: Standardizing Cyber PMM Processes (Our Tetris Shapes) First things first—we need to define our standard tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs), or as I like to call them, our Tetris shapes. Why Tetris? Because the PMM world is unpredictable, with tasks dropping in random and unexpected sequences. Being able to recognize, organize, and execute these tasks efficiently is the key to winning this game. And as AI assistants become our partners, these Tetris shapes will form the foundation for how we collaborate with technology to scale our efforts. The Role of AI in Cyber PMM Processes The future is already here: AI tools, like GPT, are revolutionizing PMM workflows. Imagine having an assistant at your disposal 24/7 to handle mundane tasks like:

  • "Create a 500-word Product Brief using this template and pull from this Messaging Brief for guidance." This can save hours of manual work. But before we reach this point, we need to establish standardized processes for AI to follow. The AI is only as good as the training and templates we provide—it’s our job to define these foundational elements. Why We Need a PMM "Mr. Miyagi" Like Daniel LaRusso in The Karate Kid, PMMs need a master—a “Mr. Miyagi”—to teach the foundational skills and processes. Without standardized practices, we risk chaos and inefficiency. Here's why this is critical:

    1. Eliminating Subjectivity: Too often, PMMs are evaluated on superficial criteria, like sending Slack messages at odd hours or appearing busy in meetings. Real productivity and value should be measured by well-defined outcomes, not appearances.

    2. Tailoring for Cyber’s Unique Challenges: Borrowing PMM processes from other industries often doesn’t work in Cyber. We need solutions tailored to our chaotic and high-pressure environment, where speed and adaptability are paramount. The Tetris Shapes of Cyber PMM Processes Here are the foundational processes—or "shapes"—that Cyber PMMs need to define and standardize:

  1. Market Understanding

    • Why It Matters: PMMs should be market experts, not just product experts. Understanding market dynamics, customer challenges, and trends is foundational.

    • AI Application: Use GPT prompts to quickly generate market overviews or synthesize analyst reports. Example:

    • "Create a market analysis for XYZ cybersecurity segment, including top trends, customer pain points, and key competitors."

  2. ICP/Persona Definitions

    • Why It Matters: Clear Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) and persona definitions drive targeted marketing.

    • AI Application: Instead of outsourcing this process to expensive agencies, we can prompt GPT to create persona definitions based on available data. Example:

    • "Define a detailed persona for a SOC Analyst, including their goals, pain points, and buying behaviors."

  3. Persona Prioritization

    • Why It Matters: Not all personas are created equal. Prioritizing personas ensures resources are allocated effectively.

    • Process Tip: Build a Persona Prioritization Matrix to rank personas based on strategic importance.

    • AI Application: Prompt GPT to generate a prioritization matrix:

    • "Rank the following personas by strategic importance for our GTM strategy: CISOs, SOC Directors, Compliance Managers, Security Analysts."

  4. Message Source Documents

    • Why It Matters: Consistent messaging is critical. A source document ensures everyone is aligned on core themes and value propositions.

    • Framework Tip: Use the "Rule of 3s" for simplicity:

    • 3 customer challenges.

    • 3 solutions your product offers.

    • 3 value pillars summarizing your differentiation.

    • AI Application: Train GPT to generate source documents:

    • "Create a messaging framework for Product XYZ, focusing on these three value pillars: visibility, automation, and threat mitigation."

  5. Message Testing

    • Why It Matters: Messages need validation before they go live. Testing ensures resonance with your audience.

    • AI Application: GPT can simulate focus groups or analyst feedback. Example:

    • "Pretend you’re a panel of 10 CISOs. Critique the following message for clarity and impact."

  6. Buyer’s Journey Maps

    • Why It Matters: Mapping the buyer’s journey ensures you’re addressing customer needs at every stage.

    • AI Application: GPT can simplify this complex process:

    • "Create a buyer’s journey map for SOC Analysts, including recommended content for each stage."

  7. Content Templates

    • Why It Matters: Templates streamline production, ensuring consistency across deliverables.

    • AI Application: Generate content plans:

    • "Build a content waterfall for Product XYZ, aligned to the buyer’s journey and ICP."

  8. Production Workflows

    • Why It Matters: Efficient workflows minimize wasted time and resources.

    • Future Vision: Tools like Canva and Adobe could integrate with GPT to directly generate polished creative assets from prompts. The Game of Tetris: Building a PMM Playbook Cyber PMMs face an unpredictable workflow where tasks drop at random—like Tetris pieces. But while the sequence may be unpredictable, the shapes themselves are not. By defining these shapes (our core processes), we create a repeatable, scalable playbook that works in any situation. Imagine a world where:

    • Every PMM knows exactly how to approach any task.

    • AI tools amplify our efforts, handling repetitive work and enabling us to focus on strategy.

    • We spend less time firefighting and more time building value for our customers. Let’s start defining these processes, train our tools, and lay the foundation for the future of Cyber PMMs. It’s time to win the game of Tetris. Part 2: Unlocking the Potential of a Cyber PMM AI Co-Pilot The next part of the vision is our ability to build effective AI co-pilots to execute standardized processes on our behalf. There has been a lot of hype around AI so I don’t want to sound like I’m drinking the kool-aid. I’m legitimately convinced that this is the future because I have been using AI tools recently and the technology is truly able to take on my advanced PMM tasks. We need to embrace this capability and try to automate as much as we can instead of trying to be heroes and hang on to the past.

But won’t AI just replace us then? Nope, it’s just another tool for us to use. Let’s move forward and use our creativity for things machines can’t do like building cross-functional consensus at work with other teams, having emotions, showing up at events in person to deliver live messages, and other “human” activities. Let the machines do what machines do. We do what humans do.Training a GPT Sidekick

A GPT sidekick can potentially do a lot of tasks for Cyber PMMs -- if we train it. This is what I call "sharpening the ax". Another way to look at it -- we need to bring in Mr. Miyagi for the Karate Kid. Perhaps a GPT can eventually execute our processes, but let’s test the waters before diving in headfirst. We also shouldn’t dismiss this technology as “all hype” without testing it first.

In part one of the vision series I listed out examples of “Tetris shapes”, or standard processes that we could eventually train a GPT on. The concept is that we'd remain captains of the ship, guiding the GPTs direction. But the heavy digital lifting—the machine grunt work—can be outsourced to a sidekick, whether it's ChatGPT or other tools. Let machines do what machines do best - they are tools for us to use. Maybe it's time to let an engine push the ship forward so we can take our oars out of the water. Sharpening the Ax

It reminds me of the old Abe Lincoln saying, "Give me six hours to chop down a tree and I will spend the first four sharpening the ax."

This quote emphasizes the importance of preparation and planning in achieving one's goals more effectively. It suggests that time spent in preparing and sharpening one's skills or tools can make the actual task at hand much more efficient and successful. And anyone that was still chopping down trees without an ax in Lincoln’s day would have been considered a bit dumb, right? So the other point here is that we need to use the tools around us in a smart way, to use more brains and less muscle wherever we can.

It’s hard not to imagine a future where PMMs are sitting in our homes, wearing headsets and speaking to a virtual assistant like ChatGPT to pump out work. I am personally excited for this future, and I don’t think it’s wise to ignore the introduction of these technologies. My expectation is that PMM teams will not be increasing in size and existing employees will be asked to do more with less due to these technological advancements (think of all the "efficiency" layoffs going on).

Therefore, the most valuable PMMs will be those that embrace this technology, and demonstrate an ability to deploy it in our daily activities. PMMs that can quickly extrapolate on how they are using technology to create a more efficient operation are going to stand out from the crowd.

Don't be frightened of this future though. If you haven't given GPTs a whirl yet, try it out. You can create a sidekick in minutes without any coding skills. I’m by no means a heavy GenAI user, or a developer with coding skills, and I was able to create an Open AI account and create a Cyber PMM GPT in less than 30 minutes. My goal is to train it to process mundane tasks, freeing up time for more strategic planning and relationship building. The vision is to outsource to Cyber PMM GPT sidekick basic requests that chew up the most time. Sample Prompts

Let’s think more about what this means to keep things practical and demonstrate what I mean through examples. Really, we’re talking about creating prompts. So let’s start to list these out based on the examples from the Defining Our Tetris Shapes post.

Tactic, Technique or Procedure (TTP) Prompt Example Market Understanding "Generate a comprehensive analysis of current market dynamics, customer challenges, and emerging trends in the market, utilizing publicly available data sources. Prioritize data found from analyst firms such as Gartner, IDC and Forrester. If you can’t find data, estimate based on available information and other market variables." Persona Definitions "Create detailed persona profiles for cybersecurity roles such as , leveraging publicly available information from social platforms and industry databases." Persona Prioritization "Develop a Persona Prioritization Matrix categorizing personas like CISOs, Compliance Managers, SOC Directors, Security Architects, Security Engineers, and Security Analysts based on the attached criteria, considering their use of , and prioritize them accordingly with a score that indicates their priority for likelihood of needing said product." Messaging Templates "Construct a 3x3 messaging template for , detailing the top three customer challenges, three solutions offered, and three value statements, culminating in three key differentiated value pillars for targeted messaging based on our persona prioritization matrix." Message Testing "Simulate message testing feedback for the attached messaging brief, adopting the perspectives of a panel with 25 time-pressed sales executives, 25 customers from varying personas, and 25 critical industry analysts complete with a British sense of wit and humor, to evaluate and refine my product messaging." Buyer's Journey Maps "Create a Buyer's Journey Map for , aligning content types with the needs of my prioritized personas at each stage of their decision-making process. While you’re at it, provide content title recommendations and blurbs that I can use to share plans around and include a phased rollout considering production time frames." Content Waterfall "Generate an innovative content waterfall mix for , incorporating market understanding, messaging, persona prioritization, and buyer's journey insights, specifying word counts, layout, and design guidelines." Production Workflows "Outline a streamlined content production workflow for cybersecurity product marketing, focusing on efficiency and cost-effectiveness, integrating GPT outputs with creative tools like Adobe’s Creative Suite or Canva. Optimize the workflow based on our content mix and eliminate any unnecessary steps." Planning “Draft a marketing plan that covers these key sections and keep it to a Plan-on-a-Page format.” or “I’ve uploaded last year’s plan on a page, and would like for you to iterate upon it based on the market research reports from these firms, as well as the list of big events I need to account for in 2024. Take into consideration the launches of the list of products found in this list as well.”

This list isn’t exhaustive - it’s a starting point to test our sidekick out later. Let's put a pin in this until I can find more time to start running these prompts against test scenarios. I might find some of these to be feasible and others more difficult, but I still want to test them out. Dispelling the AI Job Displacement Myth

Now, here's the part that might make some folks nervous: the fear of AI replacing us, rendering our roles obsolete. But here's the truth—AI is not here to snatch our jobs; it's here to be our trusty sidekicks in productivity. By automating the repetitive grind, AI liberates us to do what we humans excel at: being creative and emotionally intelligent. However, our skillset will have to adapt and meet the challenge of managing AI tools.

I’m all for embracing GenAI as a sidekick in our work. This means more time for activities that demand the human touch. Here's where our uniqueness truly shines:

  • Building Consensus: AI can't replicate the art of building cross-functional consensus at work. We understand the intricate nuances of diverse teams and can foster collaboration like no machine can.

  • Emotional Intelligence: Machines may be clever, and as much as Elon Musk tries, they don't do feelings, yet. We, on the other hand, have a knack for understanding and addressing the emotions and needs of our colleagues and customers, creating genuine connections by using empathy. I say this realizing that machines can learn how to recognize some emotions and adjust responses accordingly.

  • Personal Engagement: While AI can generate solid messages, there's no substitute for showing up in person to deliver them at events or meetings. Our personal touch adds authenticity and resonance to our interactions. We can read an audience, answer questions live, and inject humor or personal stories to enliven our messages.

  • Being Human: Beyond the work arena, we engage in a multitude of "human" activities that enrich our lives—hobbies, leisure pursuits, and adventures that make us well-rounded individuals that have actual personal lives, not just processing tasks like machines.

In a nutshell, we're letting AI do what it excels at—being efficient, precise, and automating tasks—while we focus on what makes us uniquely human: our creativity, empathy, emotional intelligence, and our ability to forge profound connections.

So, as we venture deeper into the “age of AI”, we should train tools to deliver our outputs based on testing with real-world scenarios. Doing so will allow us to sharpen our digital axes and become more effective PMMs as we fight the digital chaos around us. More importantly, we’ll get better at guiding customers as they navigate a complex buyer’s journey to try and keep their organizations safe. Part 3: Amplifying the Voice of the Customer In this third part of setting a Cyber PMM vision, it’s time to shift from being hermits to becoming customer-obsessed wizards. Amplifying the voice of the customer is the essence of product marketing—it’s the foundation upon which every other PMM function rests. If we’re not in tune with our customers, it’s like trying to play darts in the dark. Without this insight, we can’t execute effectively, and the entire business suffers. That’s why this is the third pillar of the Cyber PMM vision. The Current State of Customer Engagement Let’s be honest—many Cyber PMMs today are practically strangers to their customers. We emerge from our caves for the occasional customer interaction, but that’s about it. It’s not sustainable, and frankly, it’s ineffective. Any Cyber PMM that isn’t engaging with customers regularly is destined for irrelevance. Customer insights aren’t just helpful—they’re essential. The reality is this: customer engagement must become a daily practice for PMMs. It’s not a box to check or a quarterly event; it’s a cultural shift. This isn’t just about showing up—it’s about earning customer trust, building feedback loops, and truly understanding their needs. Think of it like nurturing a plant: consistent care and attention are required for it to grow strong. A Case Study: The Midea PMM Who Made an Impact If you need proof of what PMMs can accomplish with customer-centricity, look at the story of Midea. This company reinvented the clunky, frustrating process of installing a window air conditioning unit. They made it easier, more efficient, and user-friendly. The driving force behind this? A product marketer. Rodrigo Teixeira, Midea America’s Product Marketing Director, led a team that spent five years reimagining the product. As Teixeira put it, “We all thought: There has to be a better way of doing this.” Midea’s success is a shining example of how PMMs, armed with customer insights, can influence product development in meaningful ways. Sadly, such examples are rare in cybersecurity. The truth is, Cyber PMMs are often kept at arm’s length from customers, and this is a major missed opportunity. Five Concrete Steps to Amplify the Voice of the Customer So how do we move from the status quo to becoming customer-obsessed? Here are five actionable ways to get started:

  1. Volunteer to Staff Events

    • Why: Events like RSAC, Black Hat, AWS re:Inforce, and user conferences offer unparalleled opportunities to interact with customers directly.

    • How: Volunteer to staff booths, deliver demos, or support field teams. Make yourself visible, valuable, and approachable.

    • Pro Tip: Be part of the event scheduling process so Sales knows you’re available as a subject matter expert (SME).

  2. Connect with the Sales Team

    • Why: Sales has the closest, most frequent interactions with customers.

    • How: Build relationships with Sales leaders and reps, and ask to join customer calls. Be upfront about your intentions and respectful of their time.

    • Pro Tip: When you’re invited to a call, observe and contribute thoughtfully. Avoid dominating the conversation.

  3. Analyze Customer Call Recordings and Notes

    • Why: You can’t be on every customer call, but you can learn from the ones you miss.

    • How: Leverage tools like Gong or simply ask for access to meeting notes and recordings. If access is limited, start with what’s freely available in shared drives.

    • Pro Tip: Watch recordings at increased playback speed to save time.

  4. Perform Customer Surveys

    • Why: Surveys provide direct feedback on product features, challenges, and customer satisfaction.

    • How: Research existing survey tools and processes at your company. Craft thoughtful questions to uncover actionable insights.

    • Pro Tip: Share survey results widely to demonstrate the value of customer input.

  5. Engage in User Forums or Slack Channels

    • Why: Community forums are treasure troves of user insights and trends.

    • How: Monitor discussions, participate in conversations, and answer questions where you can. Build credibility as a helpful resource.

    • Pro Tip: Set up alerts for key topics to stay informed. Overcoming Common Obstacles You’ll inevitably face resistance. PMMs are often excluded from customer conversations by design, not out of malice but because of ingrained habits or logistical constraints. Here’s how to overcome these barriers:

    1. Prove Your Value: Show how your involvement directly benefits the customer and the business.

    2. Be Persistent: If you’re initially excluded, don’t give up. Politely request access to notes, recordings, or second-hand insights.

    3. Adapt: If live customer interactions aren’t possible, explore alternative methods like surveys or AI-driven sentiment analysis. The key is to position yourself as an ally, not an intruder. You’re there to amplify the customer’s voice, not complicate the process. Why This Matters: The Business Impact Neglecting customer insights has far-reaching consequences:

    • Weaker Messaging: Without customer input, our messaging risks being out of touch and irrelevant.

    • Missed Opportunities: Features and content fail to address real customer pain points.

    • Slower Growth: Misalignment with customer needs stifles innovation and differentiation. On the flip side, customer-centric PMMs drive business success. By understanding broader market segments, we can prioritize features and campaigns that resonate with larger audiences, not just one-off accounts. This is how we create sustainable growth and impact. The First Domino Customer engagement isn’t just important—it’s the first domino. When you start with customer insights, every other aspect of product marketing becomes more effective. Your GTM plans, campaigns, and sales enablement efforts all benefit from a clear understanding of your audience. Yes, this shift will ruffle feathers. Some teams will resist change, and others may guard customer knowledge like treasure. But without this knowledge, we’re just guessing. And in this game, guessing isn’t good enough. Conclusion: The Voice of the Customer is Our Superpower As Cyber PMMs, we have a unique opportunity to be the voice of the customer within our organizations. This isn’t just a responsibility; it’s a superpower. The more we engage with customers, the sharper our insights, the better our messaging, and the stronger our impact on the business. In the future of Cyber PMM, customer-centricity isn’t optional—it’s the foundation of everything we do. It’s time to drop the hermit act, embrace this responsibility, and lead our teams to success. Let’s get started. Part 4: Metrics are the Norm "You can't manage what you can't measure." - Peter Drucker Imagine if you opened Slack or Teams tomorrow (or whichever tool you use), and your CFO randomly asked you to articulate why you exist using clear business metrics and numbers by the end of the day. How would you answer? In the world of Cyber PMMs, this is one of our greatest challenges and opportunities. Our future in this business hinges on our ability to provide concrete metrics that objectively demonstrate our value. The fourth part of our Cyber PMM vision is a critical step in bridging this gap between our roles and the financial part of the business. Imagine if we got this right To get past the guessing games, think about what a future with measurement would like. Imagine if we got this right:

    1. Rather than focusing on "dive and catch" reactive heroics, promotions and accolades will be based on measurable performance.

    2. Entry-level PMMs would understand the criteria for success and they will be able to clearly see their priorities.

    3. We'll have fewer fire drills since the work we do is measured, so we'll be focused on what really matters.

    4. Having less confusion and more clarity about how we're doing would make for a more fulfilling career.

    5. My personal favorite - we’ll join less irrelevant calls and meetings because it will be more clear that the topic is not related to our function. Think better time management. This future is only possible if we begin to start measuring our function. This would be an industry-wide effort, and it won’t happen overnight. Virtually everything in the digital world is measurable, so there's no excuse not to put effort into resolving this issue. It’s worth a shot.Without measurement, a function is broken As with anything else, trying to improve will face resistance because it will require change, and people generally resist change. Even if it makes sense, the status quo will say, “this is how we’ve always done it so why should we change?” Sure, I like the saying, “if it’s not broke, don’t fix it” as much as anyone. But who’s saying our function isn’t broken? I mean, if it’s not measurable, isn’t it broken? I’d argue that it is broken on this basis alone. Without measurement, a function is broken. Here are the measurement obstacles for most Cyber PMM teams today:

    6. Reporting Distance & Relevance: To begin with, other marketing teams within the organization usually handle reporting. This usually means someone from another group spends very little time speaking with PMMs before they present on metrics. They use acronyms like MCP (Marketing Contributed Pipeline) or MQLs (Marketing Qualified Leads) and many others, leaving most of the PMM audience confused. These reports usually lack relevance to our function and lack individual product-level performance, so it’s natural that PMMs tune these results out. We might virtually golf clap during the presentation, but really we don’t understand if we had anything to do with the results or not.

    7. Number Distance: Cyber PMMs have long been disconnected from numbers, measurements, and tangible results. Conversations between Finance and PMM are, well, a bit awkward today. The reason is that, despite some recent improvements, Product Marketing measurement has remained largely subjective (at least in Cyber). And I’m not advocating for assigning quota’s to PMMs - I’ve seen that model fail miserably and it’s confusing at best. PMMs are not in Sales and we shouldn’t overlap functions in the business.

    8. Lack of Output Definition: Our functional outputs lack standard definitions, which makes it difficult to create metrics related to our function. It’s easier for Sales because Sales produces revenue and sells our products so this is easier to measure. I once heard someone claim that "everything is Sales" and I get the point, but Product Marketing isn't measured the same way at the end of the day. The outputs we deliver that drive actual business/financial results can and must be clearly defined. Sales Gets It I envy Sales for the reason that they know how they are being measured. Quarter after quarter, there’s little guesswork. (I do realize that not all deals are clearly going to close, and from that view, there is a lot of guesswork. I just mean there's less guesswork on how you will be measured.) During my brief time in Inside Sales over a decade ago, it was easy to tell if I was successful. I either rang the bell or I didn't; we literally had a bell on our Sales floor. The clarity was really appreciated; did I hit my quota for the month? If I did, then I still had a job. It was brutal and felt inhumane at times, but everyone knew where we stood. Perhaps that’s more humane than the alternative. I had a number to reach and everyone knew what my number was, and how close I came to reaching it. While I didn’t quite agree with the way the system was structured, it was still effective from a measurement standpoint. Frustratingly, the opposite is true in Product Marketing. We don’t have “a number”. We’re aimlessly reacting to events of the day instead of working toward concrete, measurable objectives. Annual and quarterly OKR exercises are a step in the right direction, but even they can be hurt by a lack of quantifiable objectives. It’s not as easy as, “we will build 25 product assets in Q4.” The problem here is that there is little relationship to financial outcomes. Not to say we don’t add value. I really believe we do add a ton of value to the business. But if I can’t measure that value, it’s impossible to articulate it to business leaders. We need a scoreboard like in Sales. In other words, when do PMMs “ring the bell”? Is it when MCP grows? Maybe. But even when MCP soars, PMMs don't feel connected to the result -- we're not ringing the bell. What we need is a connection between actual product sales, product adoption, business growth, and our function. This way we can see a direct connection between our role and business results. And we won’t get there without metrics which require a definition of functional outputs which I’ll address later. In the absence of widely adopted product marketing metrics, confusion prevails, leading to talented PMMs leaving the field or potential recruits avoiding it altogether. Why Do Cyber PMMs Even Exist? Clearing this confusion requires a shift toward reporting on real business metrics. This would clarify our purpose, underscore our value, and justify the investment in our roles. Without such a data-driven approach, we risk falling victim to the ever-present call for "efficiency" by CFOs. To put it in a very plain, direct way - imagine if a CFO sent you a message first thing tomorrow, asking you “Why are PMMs needed? Why do you even exist?” Ouch, painful. But I think we need to experience this pain to build a better future. To answer the CFO’s question, many of us would start discussing our contributions to recent projects like messaging, content, campaigns, events, and the million activities we are involved in. But a CFO would stare at you coldly asking for numbers. We have to stop listing random activities and begin defining our contributions to the business in real terms, so that we can then measure results. And that requires a foundation of defining our role’s core outputs. As a CMO I once worked for used to say, “we need less random acts of marketing”. By the way, this is a similar need we face when trying to adopt GenAI as I illustrated in the Defining Our Tetris Shapes: Vision 1 post. Creating Metrics - A Starting Point Let’s just start with a few foundational Cyber PMM functions without building an exhaustive list. I will take the perspective of answering a CFO asking me, “why do you exist?” Let’s start with a polite, “Thank you for the question. I would love the opportunity to expand upon this. Here are the reasons I exist - on any given day, you will find me adding value in the following ways:”

    9. Driving Market Understanding: As a Cyber PMM I am continually observing, researching, and analyzing the trends and drivers within the markets our company’s products fit in. Without this, the business will suffer due to a poor product-market fit. This is like flying blind or building a problem for your solution instead of a solution to an actual customer problem. Making a single wrong decision to engineer software that has no tangible relevance from a security practitioner standpoint is a massive waste of money. Just look at the amount of startups that rise and fall in our industry. Why is that? It’s mainly because there was a lack of true market understanding at the outset. Do you want to take that risk? We are providing the business with market awareness and intelligence so the business makes better overall investments from an engineering standpoint.

    10. Defining Buyer Personas: After defining broader market segments, knowing the buyer groups and individual personas within your ideal customer profile will pay major dividends on our overall marketing spend. Having a clearly defined target customer and profiling them will allow for targeted advertising, better selection of mediums, better trade show investments, and higher quality leads that our Sales team can convert to paying customers.

    11. Creating Differentiated Messaging: Delivering differentiated messaging leads to clarity on why a customer should choose our product over competing solutions in the market. It doesn’t solve for a terrible product, but if a solid product exists and you don’t have good messaging, the business will suffer as a result of losing deals, not being considered, and a general lack of understanding on what you do. A clear, differentiated message will lead to better Sales conversions because the buyer will already have a good understanding of what we do before expressing interest in learning more.

    12. Building Amazing Content for Buyer’s Journeys: Most buyers are doing the bulk of their research on our products using search engines, our website, and watching free videos. This is often referred to as the “Dark Funnel”, which is becoming increasingly important. If we don’t deliver upon our buyer’s needs along this journey by providing product demo’s, videos, and more content, then our competitors who are investing in this area will grab a larger market share over time, as well as being able to convince our existing paying customers to migrate to their competing solutions. There are more areas to dive into, but for the sake of simplicity, let’s just assume that this same exercise can be repeated for areas like competitive intelligence, analyst relations, peer reviews, events, testimonials, and sales enablement. And of course, the CFO would respond to my thought out answer with, “Yeah, but how do you measure all of this?” And this is the problem today. We list off our activities, but we don’t measure them. And it looks like, “activity without accomplishment” in the eyes of CFO’s. So let’s address that. Defining Cyber PMM Metrics Taking these functional areas where we have proven business value, the next step should be establishing methods by which we can measure our output on demand. What should these metrics look like? Let's turn to Sales for insight, as they are probably the most metrics-oriented function in business. Sales professionals operate under constant pressure, with clear quarterly or annual revenue targets. While this stress is a clear result of meeting or not meeting a target metric, PMMs face a different kind of uncertainty: the lack of data-driven metrics to gauge our performance. This is why I love the Peter Drucker quote, "You can't manage what you can't measure". I think it is spot on. It’s impossible to manage the Cyber PMM function without measurement. Let me correct that. It’s impossible to effectively manage the Cyber PMM function without measurement. So how do we get there? It won’t be easy. If it was easy, we’d be doing it already. To get started, we can take inspiration from Sales and consider implementing the following metrics for Cyber PMMs:

    13. Creating Differentiated Messaging:

    • Measurement Objective(s):

    1. Measure the uniqueness of messaging.

    2. Measure its resonance with industry analysts.

    3. Measure its resonance with our ideal customer profile.

    4. Measure how this messaging is contributing to business growth.

    • Possible Metrics:

    1. Analyst Feedback Scores: if we asked a GPT to act as a panel of industry analysts we briefed to provide a differentiation score on our messaging brief, we could arrive at an average.

    2. ICP Feedback Scores: Using message testing tools like Wynter, we could arrive at some way to ask groups of 15 to 50 users on their scores of our overall differentiation.

    3. Overall Differentiation Score: By combining all survey / feedback inputs into an average we could arrive at an overall score.

    4. Messaging Financial Impact: By relating the value of this messaging to improved pipeline growth, better lead generation, and conversions, we could assign a numerical value to it.

    5. Defining Buyer Personas:

    • Measurement Objective(s):

    1. Measure the impact to the business in financial terms of defining buyer personas.

    2. Measure how accurate these personas are.

    3. Measure how Sales uses your personas to improve win rates.

    • Possible Metrics:

    1. Persona Accuracy: Survey large groups of personas and ask them if the definition you created is accurate, scoring it on a scale. Then relate accuracy to win rates.

    2. Buyer Persona Usage: Measure how your work was actually used over the course of a quarter. Ask other groups how they found it useful and survey them asking for a ranking on usefulness and how it contributed to their performance.

    3. Financial Impact: Relate personas to financial results by researching the opportunities that were added to the pipeline for each persona and assessing value.

    4. Building Buyer Content:

    • Measurement Objective(s):

    1. Measure the impact to the business in financial terms of creating buyer content.

    2. Measure the use of content with buyers in terms of relevance to their decision making process while they were in the “dark funnel” and researching options.

    • Possible Metrics:

    1. Content Utilization: Survey new customers to assess the use of content within their decision making process. Or use existing tools to calculate the usage of content in the buyer’s journey across each deal closed.

    2. Content ROI: Assign a % to the value the content held in a buyer’s decision making process.

    3. Driving Market Understanding:

    • Measurement Objective(s):

    1. Measure the use of recent analyst reports and analyst message testing within your messaging.

    2. Measure the awareness of key market players, awareness of key trends, and awareness of key market drivers.

    3. Test whether or not the sales team accurately comprehends the market landscape.

    • Possible Metrics:

    1. Market Analyst Resonance: Assign a score to your product messaging briefs based on recent market analyst inputs and reports.

    2. Market Awareness: Assign a score to your product messaging briefs based on terms relating to recent market trends and drivers.

    3. Sales Understanding: Test the field on their awareness of the basic, intermediate and advanced knowledge of market dynamics.

This is just a starting point. These initial metrics will evolve over time, but they provide a foundation for establishing a more data-driven approach in Cyber PMM. The question remains: can we ever reach a point where we, as Cyber PMMs, can confidently measure, in real financial terms, the value of our work? I’m optimistic and think a solution is within reach.

And as we adopt these metrics, we pave the way for a future where our contributions are undeniable and our role is secure in the age of “efficiency”. And worst case scenario, we realize that we actually aren’t providing value, and then it’s time to have an honest conversation about changing our function altogether. We can’t lose by investigating this using a scientific approach. As the measurement of Cyber PMMs evolves, the quest for improved management of our function is becoming within reach. By aligning our roles and day-to-day activities with concrete metrics, we can finally answer the question: why do Cyber PMMs exist? The future of our role hinges on our ability to measure, adapt, and demonstrate our value in an increasingly data-driven world.

Continue the academy

Unlock all 20 modules, free.

Confirm your email once to read modules 3–20 and save your progress.

By joining, you’ll receive Cyber PMM lessons and relevant Product Marketing updates through Pathlight. Unsubscribe from emails anytime without losing training access.

or